
Dan Brown has written a book called "Angels and Demons". It is mostly set in a city called "Rome" in a country he cleverly calls "Italy", just like the real country occupying the Apennine peninsula. It is a very entertaining book, at least as long as you remember that Brown does not have any clue about the real Rome, Italy or the Italian language or anything at all, apparently. Unfortunately, it is possible that your mind slips during the reading, and you briefly think he tries to come with facts or realistic descriptions, and then your adrenaline shoots up so your head is about to explode. He for example claims that the Christian Eucharist was inspired by the Aztec and he places Argentina on the Eastern side of the Atlantic.
And then there is the linguistic aspect. After languages like Esperanto, Volapük, Lojban and Klingon, the world now has a new artificial constructed language: Dan Brown Italian, (DBI). DBI vaguely resembles real Italian, but it is largely unintelligible by any Italian. A phrase like "we're fungito" does not mean anything in Italian. A "straniero crudo" means "an uncooked foreigner", whatever that is supposed to be. And when a DBI speaker says "È chiusa temprano" to express that something is temporarily closed, an Italian speaker's natural reply would be "do you speak English, by any chance?"
In spite of the large number of factual errors, the book remains entertaining. Dan Brown did the right thing to publish it. And all his readers do the right thing in making fun of him for it.
3 comments:
När en kvinna i bokan sagt "we're fungito", så följer följande text: "Langdon knew enough Italian to know she was right." ;-)
När jag sökte på den textsträngen så såg jag att någon undrade hur det blivit "översatt" i den italienska versionen av boken. Och det kan man undra.
Some people just don't 'get' fiction. In fact, some people don't 'get' fiction so much that they write blogs saying "I really don't 'get' fiction."
It's fiction !
The entertaining DanBrownCodePod podcast mentions this blog post in some ridiculously nice (but most definitely true) words.
If you like Dan Brown, follow their podcast. If you hate Dan Brown, follow their podcast. If you do not care about Dan Brown, follow the podcast anyhow. Once you have listened to their detailed comments, you won’t have to read any of his books.
https://twitter.com/danbrowncodepod/status/978862890072596480
Post a Comment